Nation's Building News Online

Plain Text Version (Click Here for Graphical Version)

Sponsored by Countrywide Home Loans National Builder Division
and 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty

www.NAHB.org
Week of May 5, 2003

Front Page

President's Message

* There Are No Better Housing Advocates Anywhere

Regulation

* Urban Growth Boundaries Strike in San Jose
* City Claims Impact Fee Is a ‘Tax’
* Web Site Offers Help on EPA Compliance

Member Dividends

* NAHB Plays Key Role in Introducing Cost-Saving Foundations

Housing and Economics

* NAHB Works With Census on Property Tax Data
* Impact Fees Grow as Property Taxes Decline
* Home Building Rises in California, But It's Still Not Good Enough
* Spotlight on: Santa Fe

For Consumers

* The Kitchen Is the Most Important Room in the House

Small Builders and Remodelers

* Harvard Index Shows Gains in Remodeling Activity

Business Management

* Does Your Planning Software Match Your Project's Sophistication?
* Early Warning Signs Point to Possible Business Failure

Seniors Housing

* Seniors Buy Maintenance-Free Homes Close to Current Address
* Nursing Homes on the Decline

Research

* Wearable Computers a Possible Solution for Reading Blueprints

Building Systems

* Carpenter Bees Can Be Stopped From Tunneling Into Wood

Sales & Marketing

* Know Your Competition and Increase Your Sales

Labor

* Training Program Graduates Its First Class in Nashville

Building Products

* Fiber Glass Insulation Addresses Air Quality Concerns

Design

* Best in American Living Awards Accepting Entries

Building News Coast To Coast

Association News & Events

* Charlotte Builders Exemplify Ethics in Business

NBN Back Issues

 

City Claims Impact Fee Is a ‘Tax’

A case in Olympia, WA, will soon decide whether a city or municipality can claim that a regulatory impact fee is a “tax” in order to squirm out of stringent requirements to show that assessments on new development are proportionate to, and reasonably related to, the demands or needs created by the project.

In 1998, Drebick Investments was assessed a flat-rate citywide transportation impact fee of more than $130,000 as a condition for the city’s approval of a four-story office complex located on the edge of town.

Drebick argued that its project would have less impact on city streets than a typical project in the middle of the city and that traffic going to the development would use a nearby local freeway instead of going through town.


Sponsored by: Countrywide Home Loans

See how Countrywide’s Prime Rate OTC construction loan can offer more flexibility to qualified buyers.
Learn how our Home Equity Loan offers flexible payment options and the ability to reuse the funds.

A hearing examiner agreed with Drebick and noted that the impact fees paid could potentially be allocated by the city to individual transportation facilities that did not reasonably benefit the Drebick proposal. That was a violation of state law. However, a trial court later ruled that the impact fees were a “tax” and, as such, the city’s fees were not required to meet regulatory standards for “nexus” and “proportionality.”

Drebick is arguing that if the assessment is a tax, then the city needs to prove that it was authorized. Otherwise, it needs to meet regulatory standards for imposing an impact fee.

Olympia maintains that it has taxing authority under a state statute, and that it is authorized to raise revenue for transportation needed to support new development generally.

The case, Drebick v. City of Olympia, will soon be decided by the Supreme Court of Washington.

The Building Industry Association of Washington and the Pacific Legal Foundation have filed friend-of-the-court briefs supporting Drebick Investments in this case.
[ Go to Top ]


Sponsored by: 2-10 Home Buyer's Warranty

Need to Buy General Liability Insurance?
Are You Controlling Your Exposure to Moisture, Mold and Fungus?
Structural Defects, Can They Happen to You?
Insurance Coverage a Challenge?

To unsubscribe or to manage your subscription, CLICK HERE

Nation's Building News Online is produced and distributed by the National Association of Home Builders